The supplier determines whether you can keep promises made in your advertising. Delivery reliability matters more than a few cents of product cost.
Processing time, shipping options and realistic transit times, stock consistency, response speed, defect handling, willingness to include neutral packaging and invoices, and whether product documentation meets the requirements of the markets you sell to.
Place a small order to your own address. Measure actual delivery time, inspect quality and packaging, and document everything. A supplier that fails a single-sample test will fail at volume.
Have a second supplier for your best-selling product, and include quality checks in your own process. Single-source dependency is an operational risk, not a strategy.